Click to share

In the wake of Inhumans it seems like there’s a new contender for worst looking Marvel associated TV show with the release of the latest trailer for the upcoming show The Gifted.

The Gifted is according to executive producer Matt Nix set in an alternate timeline to everything else from Fox that’s been X-Men related, fully embracing the inherently confusing Marvel comics narrative device of alternate Earths and time lines.

The series centres around Lauren and Andy Strucker (Natalie Alyn Lind and Percy Hynes White) two teenagers who discover they’re mutants in a rather dramatic fashion. Which is problematic because their father Reed (Stephen Moyer) works for a faction of the U.S Government that hunts mutants. Meanwhile Lorna Dane aka Polaris (Emma Dumont), John Proudstar aka Thunderbird (Blair Redford), Blink (Jamie Chung) and Eclipse (Sean Teale) are a group of mutants trying to survive in a world where mutants are hunted and feared and the X-Men no longer exist.

The group of mutants here are alternate versions of the same mutants seen in the dark future of Days of Future Past, with the exception of Polaris. There’s nothing wrong with this as Blink is one of the best characters in Marvel’s vast X-Men universe, Blink was heading up the Exiles after escaping from the Age of Apocalypse reality, so it’s disappointing that the character will undoubtedly be underserved by the series for reasons that will become clear.

There’s definitely a lot of potential in the ideas of The Gifted, especially given the very pertinent real world parallels of bigotry, prejudice and hatred towards certain people just because of who they are. That potential is going to be hobbled by several things though one being The Gifted is on Fox rather than Netflix or HBO where writers would be able to actually engage some of the political issues the show is clearly bringing up, another is the same problem that threatens to hobble Inhumans, a TV show about a group of people with powers is very hard to pull off for budgetary reasons.

From what’s been shown so far The Gifted is like a slightly less cheesey Mutant X, which itself was essentially an X-Men show in everything but name, in fact it was so similar that Fox sued Marvel and the production companies before they filed a counter suit and then came to a settlement later.

So whilst it’d be great to see a TV show that features multi-layered fleshed out characters with engrossing character arcs and a narrative that deals with important themes that have very real parallels and features characters with powers, that’s something that the X-Men films have majorly struggled with or not even attempted and they’ve been mega budget productions. The fundamental problem with any TV show that features characters with powers is the writers are generally bound by budgetary restrictions into using those powers sparingly because showing them being used is an expensive and timely endeavour from a production perspective.

Marvel’s Netflix shows have managed to get around this by featuring characters that have powers that are easier to portray on screen because they are much more grounded and generally require more fight choreography than extensive and expensive digital effects work. There’s a big difference between Luke Cage throwing people around and shrugging off bullets and a character like Blink creating portals and teleporting or Polaris using her powers of magnetism to throw vehicles around. There’s no doubt that they could be done, and done impressively, but there’s a definite sense this show doesn’t have the budget to do it and when a show that features powers doesn’t have the budget to do them properly it becomes unintentionally comedic or it has to not take itself seriously and have a more comedic campy tone like DC’s Legends of Tomorrow.

Click to share